Completing the Puzzle: The Puzzle Subscription I’m Loving

If you love putting together puzzles but don’t love the part where your house slowly fills up with puzzle boxes, I have found such a fun solution: Completing the Puzzle.

I’m always looking for fun, screen-free ways to unwind, and there is something so satisfying about sitting down with a puzzle and watching it slowly come together. The only problem? Once you finish one, you have to figure out where to store it!

That’s what makes this puzzle subscription so clever. Instead of buying every puzzle you want to try, you rent them, complete them, send them back, and get another one.

How Completing the Puzzle Works

The idea is incredibly simple.

You choose a subscription, set up your puzzle preferences, and receive a puzzle to work on. Once you’ve finished it, place it back into the provided reusable packaging, attach the prepaid return label, and send it back. Then your next puzzle is on its way. As fast as you finish them, you can ship and receive another one!

That means you can keep enjoying new puzzles without creating an ever-growing stack of boxes in your closet.

And for someone who loves trying new puzzle designs, the variety is one of the best parts. Completing the Puzzle currently includes more than 1,300 puzzles from 40+ premium brands.

No More Puzzle Clutter!

Let’s be honest—puzzles take up space.

You finish a beautiful 1,000-piece puzzle, admire it for a few minutes, and then you’re left wondering what to do with all those pieces. Do you put it back in the box? Store it on a shelf? Donate it? And then, of course, there’s the temptation to buy another one.

With a rental subscription, you don’t have to find permanent storage for every puzzle you complete. You simply send it back and make room for your next challenge.

For me, that makes puzzling feel much more relaxed. I can enjoy the fun of completing something new without thinking about where I’m going to put it afterward.

Perfect for Cozy Nights at Home

There is something about puzzles that feels especially good in the fall and winter.

Put on a favorite show or podcast, make a cup of something warm, and spend an evening working on a puzzle. It’s an easy way to slow down and take a break from screens.

And puzzles don’t have to be a solo activity. They’re also fun to work on with your family, kids, friends, or significant other. Completing the Puzzle specifically offers plans and options designed around individual puzzlers, couples, friends, and families.

Choose Puzzles You’ll Actually Enjoy

One of my favorite features is the ability to tell Completing the Puzzle what kinds of puzzles you like. Their setup includes preferences such as themes and difficulty, so your selections can be tailored to your interests.

Whether you love landscapes, animals, colorful artwork, travel scenes, holiday puzzles, or something completely different, there are plenty of options to explore.

You can also create a wishlist, which makes it easy to keep track of puzzles you’d love to try.

What Happens When You Finish?

This might be my favorite part.

There’s no need to carefully put every piece back into the original box and then find a place for it on your shelf. You put the completed puzzle back into the reusable mailer, add the prepaid return label, and send it back.

Once the return is received, the next puzzle can be sent out.

It’s basically finish, return, repeat!

A Fun Gift for Puzzle Lovers

I also think this would make such a fun gift idea.

Instead of giving someone one puzzle, you can give them an entire season of puzzles to enjoy. Completing the Puzzle offers gift subscriptions in several lengths, including three-, six-, and twelve-month options.

It would be especially fun for someone who already loves puzzling but doesn’t necessarily need another box sitting in their closet.

My Favorite Thing About It

What I love most about the idea of Completing the Puzzle is that it makes the experience the focus rather than the stuff. Plus, we have a code! If you use EM_DUNNIGAN, you get a discount!

You get the excitement of opening a new puzzle, the satisfaction of putting it together, and the fun of choosing what you’ll tackle next—without accumulating dozens of finished puzzles.

And if you’re someone who can finish a puzzle and immediately think, “Okay, what should I do next?” this kind of subscription makes a lot of sense.

Finish it. Send it back. Get another one.

That’s my kind of subscription!

Check out more about it here, and don’t forget to use our code EM_DUNNIGAN for discount!